Xhaka captaincy is over. Great decision

by .

I honestly can’t with some fans.

‘Arsenal boos destroy Xhaka’

Can we start calling things cold-takes? The view that Arsenal fans had anything to do with Xhaka’s loss of the armband is straight out the book of ‘a sad indictment of generation social media.’

*Puts on old man frown*

Nothing is ever anyone’s fault these days. Everyone was desperately searching for an angle to help Granit out of a hole, the club span out a mental health angle the player was furious about, soft fans complained that the jeers were ABUSE, and TV journo’s in their fifties complained that we were an embarrassment (anyone else think the eighties fans had a little more to be embarrassed about than a few guys shouting at a camera after the game?). But when it came down to it, the club knew that Granit’s behaviour didn’t align with Arsenal values.

… and hallelejuah. We DO have values after all. (Fuck Mourinho)

Xhaka only has himself to blame, so put that ‘I’M SORRY CHAKA’ A4 sheet of paper in the bin. It’s not needed.

Leadership is a privilege, not a right. Being the captain of Arsenal is more than an armband, it’s a place in history, it’s a special place in the hearts of millions of fans. It’s the reason people don’t forget you (even the bad ones).

However, we must remember, the role comes with strings, one of those happens to be this:

String 1: DON’T TELL THE FANS TO FUCK OFF

It’s a real basic in any walk of life that if there are people paying you to do things, don’t curse at them. If you’re on TV and millions are watching, it’s even more essential you control your emotions, as there are often professional people in the stadium documenting your moves with static images and moving pictures.

Granit broke the string, not a surprise, he’s been playing a horrible tune his whole career. Even if I just focused on this season, we’ve had him tell the fans the squad was scared against Watford, he laughably threw the strikers under the bus after his howler against Spurs at home, and Emery was so worried about the announcement he had to throw an election. One month in, he slow-walked after being subbed off early for the second game in a row, then he told the fans to fuck off twice before storming down the tunnel.

Booing is part of sport. Deal with it. It’s not nice, but it’s part of the theatre. Sport is for the people and those people have a right to a voice. Those lucky enough to make a living out of the game are rewarded beyond their wildest dreams. Fans that take time out of their day to drop over £100 to see the players put on a show and give their heart for the cause. When they slow walk, it’s insulting. The jeering might not have been our finest moment as a fanbase, but nor has watching Xhaka plod around for £90k a week for 3 years.

String 2:

When a manager has taken a drive-by shooting in the arse to make you captain, you follow his orders. Emery denounced Xhaka after the game, which was code for: ‘Fucking apologise fast and don’t turn this into a PR debacle.’

Granit did not apologize. He made exec leadership look weak and he embarrassed the manager. Then when he finally apologized, he found a couple of grotty Instagram comments to justify his childish behaviour. He didn’t even apologise in English or through the club. Arsenal had to put his German Instagram Story in the club programme. I can only imagine this meant he literally wouldn’t talk to anyone all week.

Regardless, the non-apology-apology is not the sort of thing leaders do. If I were advising him, I would have recommended something like this.

I want to take this moment to apologise to all the fans. 

My actions last Monday were not in line with the values of Arsenal football club, nor were they befitting of the armband. 

I’ve recently become a new father, an exhausting period of my life which may have contributed to my misstep. I have spoken with the manager and my teammates to express my upset at my actions (Freddie helped explain to Unai what I said). I now look forward to putting myself back in contention for a starting place next week.

Up the Arse. Fuck the Spurs. Big GX 

Sadly, he didn’t do this.

That meant the manager had no choice. Xhaka thought he was above the basic rules of any club captain and his public display of defiance risked diminishing the authority of the coach even further.

Emery made a great decision.

It’s literally the luckiest accident in his short Arsenal career to date. Xhaka been a bang average for us, his skillset is wholly unsuited for the league, and his temperament is extremely questionable. His performances have been consistently substandard, the only hope we had was that he trained well and could offer a captaincy built on Arsenal values. It took him less than a month to prove himself wholly inadequate. The Scaramucci of captains indeed.

Step up Auba.

A great appointment that no one can really argue with.

He’s a captain that will lead by example.

He’ll bail us out of bad situations. He has a great personality on and off the pitch. The fans love him.

I think a year down the line, we would have had more options, but considering the circumstances, this really is absolutely fine.

Final interesting part of the Xhaka story is there might not be a way back into Emery’s plans. Again, you can’t argue with this outcome. He’s a good squad player, but now he’s had a taste of being king, it’s highly unlikely he’ll go back to being a mere mortal.

Not sure this whole debacle has done much for his resale value, but be real, you think Europe’s elite were going to purchase him without looking at a few videos first? Regardless, that’s not our worry. The fact is, we’re a better team without him.

Vitoria this evening. An unusually strong squad from Emery. He’s taken Tierney, Bellerin, LT and Leno. I worry he’s having a Europa Attack, symptoms tend to be playing his most important players against pub teams because you fear you won’t make the top 4.

I fully expect to win this game 4-0, then revert to type against Leicester at the weekend.

See you in the comments and please take in the podcast before it becomes dated!

DropboxiTunes | Stitcher | Spotify

232 Comments
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
Chika

Is there any sane human still willing to give Emery till the end of the season?

TR7

‘Enjoyed that, very organised and disciplined display against a side in great form. It will be entertaining stuff if we manage to harness the performance of the last 10 mins away at Leicester. Goals galore at last.’

Any thoughts on the quality of their midfield vis a vis ours ?

Redtruth

The big improvement was seeing the back.of that frsud Wenger.
At least Emery’s endeavours have been honest.

Chika

TR7

If you think we have the players to stand up to Leicester City, then you don’t see the game well, no question. 😋

Champagne charlie

Tr7

Obviously that’s one of the major issues here, our midfield isn’t comparable to the likes of Evangelista and Agu, so it was always an uphill battle against genuine quality like that – no fault of Emery.

Bob N16

Ceballos (from the Athletic) ‘he’s a conjuror with a ball at his feet; without it it he looks like he’s wading through treacle’.

There was only one successful pass into Vittoria’s penalty area in the whole game ( Pepe’s free kick for Mustafi’s headed goal).

Champagne charlie

Bob N16

It actually bothers me no end how much Vardy is looking forward to mugging us off. He celebrated against Palace by ‘doing the eagle’ to mock them.

I cannot stand his muggy face at all so I’m not looking forward to Saturday. Ironically it could be just that you’ve noted which is their downfall – pressure/expectation.

Though perhaps sadly it’s too soon in the season to see that and instead we’ll just get the humiliation on the cards.

Bob N16

Red, is that your best euphemism for Emery that he’s ‘honest’?

Redtruth

All this excitement over sacking a manager after years of excusing the previous manager

Guernsey Gun

What a mess…comes to something when I’m dreading an away game at Leicester. It is quite clear that Dick has no idea or ability to turn this round, needs to go now. Football has gone mad if Bayern want Wenger, in any capacity but at least it would give me something amusing to watch should it happen.

Champagne charlie

Excitement and Arsenal in the same sentence…

What a mong.

Bamford10

Yeah, sorry, but last night doesn’t change the fact that we have weak central midfield options and weak CB options. Everything I and others have said on that point remains correct.

TR7

Chika

I am only 32, so obviously not a student of the game for 30 years. I have a lot of catching up to do, an uphill task.

Bob N16

CC I never like to see Arsenal lose, but if I can derive any comfort from Leicester this Saturday it’ll be that Sanhelli and Edu pull the plug on Emery. If by some miracle( or a day of clinical finishing from PEA) we get a result I hope that the board still recognise that we can’t go on as a club with a coach who is struggling so badly. I was being slightly ironic at the possibility that Leicester could be affected by too much expectation, however clutching at straws, maybe there is a slight hope! Emery will probably go… Read more »

Bob N16

Red, worth staying in the present, not living in the past, surely?

Champagne charlie

Bob

I’m never on board with us losing, aside from moments of sheer frustration, because it’s pie in the sky that what we think will come of it is actually what comes of it.

Huge concern if the result at Leicester has any bearing whatsoever on Emery’s future. He’s cooked, I want us to somehow derive a win and then for Raul and Edu to do the obvious.

That’s the sign of in-tune, competent leadership. We shouldn’t need a mini Chernobyl for someone to finally hit the kill switch. We’ve been there.

Bamford10

Pedro was forced to delete that entire post and all of the comments that went with it, but let’s remember the exchange yesterday when I quoted Emirates as saying we need new CBs and new CMs and that said overhaul will cost some £150m. When I pointed out that one can’t acknowledge that and still claim that what we have been seeing in the PL is all on the manager, Charlie replied disingenuously that people haven’t been claiming that it’s all on the manager. I then pointed out the obvious: most Emery-outers here have in fact been saying (implicitly or… Read more »

Bob N16

True CC, put him out of his misery, a mercy sacking!

Redtruth

Fans wanting us to lose then bitching at Emery for losing….hilarious…

guest man aka WW

Leicester is the home team of my partners family..ive watched them a lot recently..and witnessed an absolute thumping defeat at the king stadium last season.
They were not only quicker, more aggressive and stronger, they carved lots of chances…3-0 flattered arsenal.
Anyone thinking its a game we should win is delusional….their mental state is alarming.
If Emerys arsenal tenure depends on this I hope we get another 3-0.

guest man aka WW

@ c.c good point…I agree…can we take the chance on winning though?

Bob N16

Red, did we lose?

Champagne charlie

Banford Player poverty isn’t the issue that you present, I addressed this yesterday too. Where it’s arguable we have squad holes relative to the top 4 battlers and beyond, we absolutely don’t have player poverty when dealing with the remainder of the league. Teams like Wolves, Leicester, Palace, Everton…..Brighton. All where “player poverty” has been cited as our reason (not “part of”) for failing to perform/win in the last year by yourself. In short, spare us all you dimwit. The reason we didn’t make top 4 last season was Emery, the reason we’re dogshit this season is Emery. When a… Read more »

Freddie Ljungberg

Didn’t watch the game last night, fell asleep before it started which seems to have been a blessing. We still have weaknessess in the squad, we still have players adapting to the league and we’re forced to rely on young players too much but we should still be doing much better than this. Bad decisions, lineups and formations, time for a new manager. I was always prepared to give any new manager a chance with the poor squad we had last season and I think Emery did pretty well until the last 6-7 games in the league but it’s been… Read more »

Tony

So many times we thought another poor tippy tappy performance or a soul destroying loss would be the final nail in Wenger’a managerial coffin, but it took a half empty Emirates and the potential of long-term losses of revenue that finally drilled it home to Kroenke and the board to come to their senses and remove Wenger. We waited years or in some cases like me over a decade for Wenger to be moved on. Whatever the outcome against Leicester I just can’t see the plug being pulled and Emery fired. The silence from Edu and Raul is unrealistic considering… Read more »

Graham62

Just to let you all know, there is absolutely no chance we get a result on Saturday.

Chika

Another one finally embraces the light.

terraloon

Oh how some on here laughed at Chelsea. Hazard , their top scorer out the door. Ha Ha Transfer ban. Ha Ha Appointing a novice in Lampard.Ha Ha No one to score goals. Ha Ha Abramovich denied a visa. Giggle Giggle. Meanwhile at Arsenal some claimed a top transfer window. Fourth position or above a walk in the park. Champions League here we come. All bar the the shouting the season is a third done and the stark reality is that Arsenal as a club are in a mess. Players openly showing dissent and content for the supporters and manager,… Read more »

Valentin

I can understand why Emery elected to go with the 3-4-3 formation. However his personnel selection and implementation were incoherent, sloppy and confusing. In a 3-4-3 against a 4-5-1, the 2 central midfielders run the risk to be overrun by the opposition 3. To counteract that, coaches put a ball player in the centre CB. That player can step in the midfield. He restarts game or help switching the play by long diagonals. That’s a role Sokratis is wholly unable to play. His limited passing ability meant that Ceballos has to fetch the ball amid the CBs, completely nullify any… Read more »

Bob N16

Fair summary Valentin. I also noticed how flat our front three was. Watching City later the contrast was stark. The angles, triangles the City players were creating allowed lovely passing combinations. For Arsenal we had two CM players trying to do the work of three players as we were over manned on the flanks.

How does a coach, who clearly is near the top of his profession, get it so wrong?

Bob N16

Tony, I disagree on the implications of the silence from Sanhelli and Edu, I think the silence is deafening. I know a statement of support can sometimes sound the death knell for a coach but in this case I think the continued, poor performances of the team will do the talking. There will be very few observers who would feel Emery to be hard done by if he is let go now. Journalists, ex players and fans are fairly unanimous in their bemusement towards his tactics and that he’s had a reasonable amount of time to show progression. He’ll be… Read more »

Moe

Bad midfield and bad defence my ass…………Emery owns that defence now, no more excuses. Ditto, the entire team.