Monchi released by Roma: Fan opinion mixed on his tenure

by .

Well, well, well… Spurs. What have we here? Looks like another case of the CHOKES. As Dan from the pod put it, what we are witnessing looks very much like a case of ‘Le Spiral de Negativiteé.’

Very amusing. Spurs are reaching a situation where their World Cup battered squad is struggling to make physical ends meet between Champions League and the race for Top 4. Tomorrow, Arsenal will be one point behind them if they win, United will be level points if they win, and if Chelsea ramp up the pressure and win their two games in hand, they will jump them.

Oh my, what a whirlwind this race is. Imagine if Spurs drop into the Europa League after opening the Nike Toilet Bowl? Would be sweet… real sweet. Only worry is the Champions League is looking fairly weak sauce at the minute. So there’s always the horror scenario where they fall up the stairs and win that. Doubtful, but let’s cover the bases so we don’t look silly.

On the Technical Director front, the mighty Monchi has severed ties with Roma in a sweeping week in which the American leadership team also exited their manager. Make no mistake, if they’d wanted to keep the Spaniard, they’d have angled for a fee. The new team looks like it’ll be either Piero Ausilio and Massimiliano Mirabelli as the Sporting Director and Ranieri as the manager. The exLeicester boss is just out here racking up millions in dismissal fees this season, unreal work.

If you want the YES MONCHI IS COMING, take a read of this.

Today’s thoughts are a little more sober because I have done some digging.

His tenure at Roma has been bland. He wheeled and dealed very hard and made zero friends with the local ultras. At an airport, Roma fans shouted, “You have destroyed the team”, to which he responded, “sure you are better… In 6 months I come to take you all one by one ”

What did I say about him looking like a Netflix crime boss? Seems he’s the real deal. Full on John Gotti threats in an airport. Love it.

There are a few questions that have to be asked here… if he’s being panned for moving on talent, you have to work out if that was a command from the American owners. He dropped a 60m euro profit in his first window and an 18m euro profit last summer. If that was to support the new stadium, it simply means the fans aren’t as financially sympathetic as Arsenal’s.

I think the main upset comes from the fact that he hasn’t delivered the hits he was dropping for Sevilla. For me, the big red flag is that last summer, when he had a little more financial freedom to move bodies, his two marquee signings were Nzonzi and Pastore who are both 29 years old and far from elite. If you’re picking them up on free transfers, sure, but dropping 60m euros on them is pretty crazy. For a man that slagged British clubs for being profligate, those two really are perplexing buys.

It’s always good to raid the fan blogs for a bit of blood and thunder opinion. This SB Nation blog gives a very fair overview of his tenure.

On why he failed:

‘The club’s strategic direction comes from the top. I place his failures more on Pallotta’s philosophy of flipping players rather than building a winning team. What I am curious about is whether he was angling his way out prior to the last few weeks. Of course with EDF fired his position was untenable and he had no choice but to resign. I’m disappointed with the decisions he made but surely this Roma side needed at least another year or two before it would reach its peak and represent Monchi’s vision?’

‘Two years is far from sufficient to judge him, which makes his resignation all the tougher to swallow. If, however, we view it as a principled stance in support of EDF and/or his own autonomy as DS, then I can certainly respect that. In the end, I just don’t think his big purchases worked out as quickly as he needed them to, which looked worse in the face of the Salah and Alisson sales. And then there’s the wrinkle we’ll never know: how much independence did he actually have and to what extent was he limited by Roma’s financial health.’

On his failings:

‘The manner in which he short shrifted the defense. His right backs had about two healthy ligaments between them while his left backs were either living on borrowed time (Kolarov) or were too handsome to be good footballers (Santon). The less said about Moreno and Marcano the better. Roma’s defense was a disaster waiting to happen, and as we saw this season, it, uh, happened.’

‘Sometimes it felt as if Monchi would spend big on a name just to have spent big on a name. Pastore and NZonzi spring to mind immediately. Perhaps there were brand concerns at play (I remember there being significant rumors that Qatar Airways funded the Pastore purchase), but he didn’t seem to have a handle on the type of player who could succeed at Roma who was already in their late 20s.’

On his successes:

‘Cengiz Under was a great signing and I’m hopeful we will say the same about Cristante next season. Zaniolo was a remarkable find, kudos.’

‘Zaniolo is the popular answer around here and it truly was a masterpiece from Monchi. But I think Justin Kluivert can truly turn into something special in a year or two. Whether it’s at Roma or another club, that’s the question. Pallotta and co better keep him in Rome as long as possible.’

Conclusion:

The jury is out. He brought in some good young players that didn’t have the chance to show their worth. He made some bad senior signings. He couldn’t mend the defence (gulp). He wasn’t afforded enough time for anyone to make a fair assessment (he also tied himself heavily to Eusebio). Additionally, what I do admire: he took full responsibility for his failings. We lack accountability at Arsenal, the club is always looking for excuses. It takes true leadership to own up to your fuck ups. Extra pertinent when you’ve got Wenger reimagining the StatDNA investment like he unearthed the scouting equivalent of Google Search.

We are in a situation with Monchi like we were with Unai Emery. Both last attained greatness at Sevilla, the big question is: can they level-up? Are we hiring in the Europa League A-listers… or is the magic of the two together like the pairing of Peter Taylor and Brian Clough?

Here are some other questions you have to ponder.

Does our leadership have long-term thinking top of mind?

When Monchi and Emery last worked together, the average age of their signings sat at 27 years old. Emery, Monchi and Raul are big fans of sniffing out bargains from the elite clubs around Europe. Raul, I hear, is a huge fan of Malcolm who has had big issues at Barcelona. No doubt we’ll be in for him in the summer.

Does that strategy have legs? Is that how you make it back to the elite?

The mode of operation that worked best for Monchi was to flip players like houses. Identify value in the market, fix up a player, and shift them on in two seasons. That’s not a longterm view. That’s chasing the instant success dragon in a league where the major clubs are thinking in a more long-term manner.

Denis Suarez was our only punt in January, we’ve barely seen him, but he is exactly the sort of player Monchi hunts down.

The other question I have is this: Is Monchi a great chief scout, or is he a great technical director? Say what you will about Marc Overmars, but he and some of the Ajax European Cup winners have turned the club around. The youth team has churned out some wild players, the senior buys have looked smart, the football is back to its most powerful, and the job that he’s been there since 2013. Ajax has been nowhere, now they are back to resembling their best.

What are Arsenal’s objectives? Who knows… but my worry is that we’re not going to be thinking 10 years ahead. Are we bringing in builders, like Jobs, Hastings or Zuckerberg, or are we bringing in 1 term politicians who need to prove themselves now? We could punt for a brighter instant future and win big, sure, that’d be amazing. The real cost though is what happens if that plan fails. What do we fall back on? What happens if our second attempt at expensive greatness flops?

We fade into terminal mediocrity…

There is a lot riding on this hire. A lot riding on a contacts transfer approach. A lot riding on two people moved on by their clubs under dark clouds.

Could be magic though… it could be.

There’s a huge game today. Top 4 is within spitting distance. Emery seems to have less problems motivating and planning strategems when it comes to bigger sides, though he didn’t do very well against United at the last attempt.

It’s clear that United will be happy to give us possession. They’ll look to find pace on the counter with long diagonal balls. They’ll more than likely lean on the huge wave of luck that’s followed them around. Lukaku is in great form, as is most of their frontline.

We gave up the advantage of freshness when Emery fielded a very strong team in the midweek defeat against Rennes. He’s going to have to dust down those deflated souls and inject some of that energy of Spurs away into the affair.

This is our top 4 cup final. Win and we have by far the best run in. Lose, and those away days are going to look like an uphill struggle.

This is mega. It’s going to be a great game of football. Let’s see what side Emery brings to the battle.

See you in the comments. x

1K Comments
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
Paulinho

What is Kola doing………….

Leftsidesanch

Would be great to see Ramseys bro get on the scoresheet.

Dissenter

“We have away matches at Watford, Wolves, Leicester and Burnley. Top 4 is not a certainty’

True…but we have played all the top-6 teams already

Siddharth14

It seems Auba just said to Mustafi …
” Good to see you on the bench mate !!”

Champagne charlie

Un

Was in amongst the pen celebrations mate. Innocuous by comparison to the others of late, but guy ran up and mocked Smalling face to face before stamping about like a mong in celebration. Embarrassment to us

Dissenter

Paulinho
“What is Kola doing………….”

He returned his dinner back to the earth.
It’s called saving the planet.
Messi used to it all the time…did him some good

Samesong

Diss

Nothing strange about Emery decisions today. Pack the midfield and one up top to see out game.

Dissenter

Suarez proving me wrong

Wenker-wanger

@versus..well said…emery is doing a really good job with mostly Wenger’s average players.
Emery’s tactics are well admired by managers and pundits alike.

Victorious

AMN well In againAre you watching maaaaarkoooo”

Lol, poor marko has ran back to her hole after making of fool of herself yet again with that first doofus comment

PessimisticPat

Jail time charlie and 5 year banning order from all UK football,

Un Battle Angel

loveky from Suarez

Er who said united had a better squad??
Hang your heads in shame

Maaaaarkoooo

Dissenter

Iwobi shouldn’t be show-boating in the 84th minute because there will be at least 5-5 minutes of added time

Samesong

Diss

That should of been a corner. Tbf

Dream10

Good carrying from Denis there

Think Emery is just taking his time with Suarez. More than likely he’ll be our wide player signing.

Champagne charlie

Disagree. Arsenal should always showboat against United given the opportunity, do you not remember Nani?

Dissenter

Suarez plays with a lot of intelligence tbh

Un Battle Angel

Great from AMN

Are you watching maaaaarkoooo

qna

Suarez looking good tonight I have to say.

Victorious

Suarez having a good little cameo

Samesong

Awe Eddies on look at that!

Mics_

Nketiah? An odd substitution.

Thomas

Lacazette is an average striker.

Un Battle Angel

Cc

Yeah that’s not cool

Siddharth14

Suarez really showed something there. It can be certified for MOTD highlights.

Dissenter

Laca is not playing midweek

Why??

I like Nkettiah but this game is far from won

Leftsidesanch

The Sky broadcast are beside themselves at us being infront in this game.

Victorious

Great from AMNAre you watching maaaaarkoooo

LMAO.. Keep it coming. Cracks me up everytime

Samesong

Nketiah? An odd substitutio
No it’s alike for
Like. Jeeez some of you guys really come out with some mess.

Paulinho

Fuck off rain.

Just comes along in time to throw a spoke in proceedings.

TR7

Top performance from Xhaka

Leftsidesanch

Xhaka held onto the ball too long there but we got away with it.

Dissenter

Maybe with this loss, United luck may run dry

They’ve had a lot of lucking their current good run

Wenker-wanger

Fergie time will be 7 minutes…good job its not at old toilet…would be 12 minutes….
Please hold on arsenal….there’s only one club I really hate losing to its manure…

Un Battle Angel

Yeah that was lovely from Suarez

Very wilshere-esque

Samesong

Great play by both youngsters there.

qna

Watch him add a ridiculous number of minutes for injury time.

Leftsidesanch

I think providing we see this out we are 15 points better off than at this stage last season.

bennydevito

This ref is fucking bent as fuck.

Dissenter

A draw will feel like a 8-2 loss right now

bennydevito

Never a yellow on Kolasinac.

LeMassiveCoq

Fergie time

Leftsidesanch

The referees are a joke though, don’t want to hear no crap about our league being the best in the world. With incompetent officials like what we see every week?

Samesong

How many times has AMN made that tackle today my man of the match.

Paulinho

Unreal United with their last ditch clearances.

Un Battle Angel

Cool head from xakha again

Paul pog who??

Are you watching maaaaarkoooo

qna

When do we ever get 5 minutes when we need it. Fucking joke.

Dissenter

In fairness to Emery
He saw OGS out in his youngsters and Feld what the hell…brought in his as well.

Wenker-wanger

Only 5 minutes!…jeez that must be frustrating for the united management…

LeMassiveCoq

Hahaa Rashford Smashford.

Leftsidesanch

Why is there 5 minutes additional?

Un Battle Angel

Great clearance from AMN with his left foot

Are you watching maaaaarkoooo

Dissenter

Bot sides have settled into the result

Tired legs and minds all over the field

Paulinho

Players need to stay switched on here.

Un Battle Angel

Emery gets it right in a big game again

Just goes to show we can compete with anyone in this league except for city with this squad

Are you watching maaaaarkoooo

Siddharth14

That penalty call aside. We really have controlled Manu in the second half.

Credit to Emery and Our players…

DaleDaGooner

Back again!

Samesong

Martial is rapid as hell.

Victorious

How many times has AMN made that tackle today my man of the match”

Don’t let Marko see this, she thinks AMN was our weakest link and has had a shocker.. Yea the bitchy marko

Wenker-wanger

Maitland Niles will have grown immensely in this game..
Cmon arsenal see these mancs off…

Leftsidesanch

Theres not a team I hate more than United and this current average side has been talked up far too much. This is very satisfying ending Oles unbeaten Prem run as their manager.

DaleDaGooner

Can’t understand why AMN wasn’t playing RB in France

Un Battle Angel

The atmosphere at the Emirates is getting better

Champagne charlie

This was a great time to play United, but make no mistake this was a good Arsenal performance and a good Emery one.

We won the battle in CM today with Rambo and Xhaka dovetailing well. The away games will be our acid test.

Leedsgunner

Our best performance in terms of control and maturity. This side is so infuriating. Why didn’t we play like this against Tottenham?

DaleDaGooner

Theres not a team I hate more than United and this current average side has been talked up far too much. This is very satisfying ending Oles unbeaten Prem run as their manager.

Amen!! The commentary was appalling leading up to this, it was like Arsenal was some lower team and it was all about United

Samesong

Theres not a team I hate more than United and this current average side has been talked up far too much. This is very satisfying ending Oles unbeaten Prem run as their manager.

Left I agree 100%

Dissenter

Hopefully we do the business on Thursday before getting a long break

qna

You fucking beauty.

Guns of sf

Amn and xhaka great today

TR7

Ole hype train brought to a grinding halt ☺️

Paulinho

Can jot another game to the list that Emery has managed well.

Victorious

CC

Agree but You have to fancy for us for 3rd/4th now.. This was a 6 pointer

bennydevito

Get in there you beauties!

Wenker-wanger

Well done Emery and the team…great result..

Dissenter

AMN is the player of the match for me

Guns of sf

Amn needs more chances

Jim Lahey

Get in!

Siddharth14

Young should be retired by now. Staggering to see him still have this pace.

Clean sheet !!!!! :))

LeMassiveCoq

Dicks Red Army!!

Thomas

They won the ” beat Man Utd at home” trophy. Instagram selfies and open bus parade coming up.

qna

Leno MoM. Xhaka fantastic. AMN great 2nd half lad. Kos is a champ.

Mr Serge

Great result today we could have a st toterings day again this season

Dissenter

There are still 7 games to go

Hold the celebrations. this just gives us a chance

jasongms

Emery knows 🙂

TR7

‘Theres not a team I hate more than United and this current average side has been talked up far too much. This is very satisfying ending Oles unbeaten Prem run as their manager.’

My sentiments exactly

Zeus

I gladly eat my words. Well done boys!

DaleDaGooner

The atmosphere at the Emirates is getting better

Yeap!

Fantastic win boys!!!!!!

Paulinho

I was always okay with the Xhaka-Ramsey partnership. Thought it worked well last seaon and was never a glaring issue in terms of both knowing their roles. Saw it in the Cup final against Chelsea as well.

Un Battle Angel

Yeeeeesssss!!!

Fucking knew it today
Good line up
The right formation
Solskjaer playing 442 played into our hands
Emery called it right
Leno, AMN, xakha, Ramsey and lacazette were quality

Are you watching maaaaarkoooo

Dissenter

Xhaka is on the 5 winners of man of match award
He had a spotless game

Moray

It’s been a great weekend for us. There’s a lot to be said for breaking man U’s run of away wins and away scoring. Pressure joe on Spuds and Man U, both of whom have champions league to distract them.

Zeus

Leno man of the match easily.

Samir

Fucking GET IN THERE!!!!

Victorious

Emery was spot on today, h’es seems to be more clued up when facing the top teams

Beginning to like the man more

Un Battle Angel

Dissenter

All due respect mate
Get bent
That’s the difference with London fans and yank fans
You just don’t get it. Not properly

TR7

Ok, so two good performances from Emery – Totts and United.

Marko

Good stuff. Good performance a bit of luck and a clean sheet happy days. Can’t be underestimated how massive a win this is. We win while Spurs Chelsea and United drop points it’s huge. Spurs and United were our toughest games in the run in and we’ve come through them very well.

Xhaka’s best game for Arsenal today

rollen

be careful what you wish for lol

Pedro and ex akbs how do u like this?

Champagne charlie

Un

We had won 8 in a row at home mate, that’s 9.

We’re 2 wins in 10 away from home. This was only in doubt given Uniteds recent renaissance, we’re good in London. Away from home will have to sharply improve

1 5 6 7 8 9 11